As a logistics provider, you’re probably all-too-familiar with these business scenarios:
Your ops manager pours over spreadsheets trying to identify why a key shipping lane has seen a sudden spike in costs.
Your sales team struggles to recapture lost customers because they lack the insights to predict and address volume drop-offs proactively.
Your leadership is targeting missed opportunities to improve margins and streamline operations, often due to incomplete or delayed insights.
In each of these cases, conducting a thorough lane performance analysis offers a solution—and the benefits will extend to multiple roles within your business. Operations managers can use lane analysis to select the best carriers for any given lane or better understand carrier costs per lane, sales teams can leverage it to retain customers and win back business, and leadership can use lane analysis to drive strategic decision-making and ROI.
In fact, when you’re trying to determine if investment in analytics is worth it, consider this: in an ROI study by CloudRating, they looked at more than 200 software investments, and the data & analytics category proved to have one of the highest ROIs at a whopping 345% after just three years.
By focusing on the right mix of cost and functionality, 3PLS and freight brokers can achieve these high returns on their analytics investment and tackle a number of high-value use cases. Here’s where you should focus for the most tangible financial and operational gains.
High-Value Use Cases for Lane Analysis
Lane Profitability Benchmarking
One of the foundational uses of lane analysis is to compare your actual costs on any given lane with your own lane portfolio averages. This analysis enables you to pinpoint lanes where your costs are above average rates and identify carriers contributing to these discrepancies. By understanding these dynamics, you can:
Carrier Negotiations: Use your insights to get better rates with higher-cost or underperforming carriers.
Carrier Shifting: Determine if you should transfer volume to more cost-effective carriers.
Cost Monitoring: Continuously review trends over time to ensure sustained improvements.
For example, if your lane analysis reveals that some carriers consistently charge significantly more than average rates for similar services, you may be able to negotiate new rates or find alternative carriers and ultimately lower overall shipping costs to boost to your bottom line.
Carrier Performance & Selection
Beyond cost, carrier performance plays a pivotal role in achieving ROI. Lane analysis can help you identify carriers that deliver consistent service and align with your operational goals. Here’s how:
Scorecarding: Measure carrier performance metrics such as on-time delivery, accident history, and compliance with requirements.
Carrier Optimization: Reduce the number of carriers per lane to simplify management and improve service consistency, using carriers that are best-suited to specific lanes
Performance Trends: Track the historical performance of each carrier to anticipate future reliability.
For instance, using lane analysis to consolidate carriers on a heavily trafficked lane from 15 to 5 can streamline operations, enhance relationships with high-performing carriers, and reduce administrative overhead. While the upfront effort to qualify and consolidate carriers may require time, the long-term gains in efficiency and reliability are significant.
Missed Opportunities & Volume Retention
Freight brokers often face challenges with declining shipment volumes, which directly impacts revenue. Lane analysis enables proactive volume management by identifying potential drop-offs in shipment volume before they occur. Measurement of two metrics in particular can improve your operations:
Customer Volume Retention: Monitor customer’s shipping behavior to identify early signs of churn and contact at-risk shippers to recapture lost loads.
Near-term forecasts: Forecasting near-term trends (for cost, income, and margin) will proactively identify trends that could affect future costs, revenue, and profitability.
For example, imagine your lane analysis reveals a trend of 20 fewer loads per month on a specific lane. With an average margin of $200 per load, that’s a potential loss of $4,000 monthly. If you can identify the problem and address the issue early enough to stop loss and recapture half the volume, you can generate an additional $2,000 monthly revenue, offsetting the cost of analytics tools and driving positive ROI.
Shipment Consolidation Opportunities
Shipment consolidation is another avenue for unlocking ROI. A thorough lane analysis can help uncover these opportunities by analyzing the geographic and timing patterns to identify cases where multiple shipments can be combined into a single load to reduce costs.
Cost Savings: Identify patterns where multiple smaller shipments can be merged to cut down on fuel, handling, administrative costs, and operational overhead.
Environmental Impact: Consolidating shipments can also reduce the overall carbon footprint, supporting sustainability initiatives.
Customer Satisfaction: Consolidation can improve delivery times and reduce shipping costs, benefiting both the broker and the customer.
For example, if your data shows that three shipments were sent on the same day to/from the same locations, consolidating them into one load could save on fuel, handling, and administrative costs. While this may require coordination with customers, the potential savings make it a worthwhile endeavor.
Improved Productivity Through Faster Analysis
An often-overlooked benefit of lane analysis is its ability to enhance productivity. By providing instant access to critical insights, analytics tools eliminate the need for manual data gathering and interpretation. This increased efficiency allows brokers to:
Automate: Spend less time on repetitive tasks and processes and more time on strategic decision-making and value-added work.
Focus: Redirect resources toward higher-value activities, such as customer relationship management or business development.
For example, a team previously dedicating 40 hours a month to manual reporting can reallocate that time to projects that drive growth. The ROI here is not just in cost savings but in overall organizational effectiveness.
Putting it all Together: Lane Analysis ROI
ROI calculations for your analytics-related projects and expenses are an exercise in estimating and consolidating the benefits from all of the above activities. The total ROI is the sum of each individual activity, for instance:
Volume Retention ROI: Recovering 20 loads per month with an average margin of $200 per load adds $4,000 in monthly revenue.
Improved Productivity ROI: Automating lane analysis frees up 40 hours of team time, which translates to $2,000 in value (at $50/hour).
Total ROI = Volume Retention ROI + Improved Productivity ROI.
Lane analysis is a game-changer for freight brokers looking to boost their ROI. By honing in on key areas like cost benchmarking, carrier performance, volume retention, and shipment consolidation, brokers can uncover huge savings and efficiencies. Operations improvements can provide benefits beyond just cost reduction — the extra productivity from using smart analytics tools can make a big difference in how your team operates and grows.
Commentaires